Everywhere You've Seen These 'Supernatural' Guest Stars Before
  • Photo:
    • Supernatural
    • The CW

Everywhere You've Seen These 'Supernatural' Guest Stars Before

Sawyer Grant
Updated January 14, 2025 74.1K views 10 items
Ranked By
3.2K votes
542 voters
Voting Rules
Vote up the well-known actors you forgot made appearances on 'Supernatural.'

The CW's Supernatural started out as a cult hit before reaching mainstream popularity. It's also become a starting vehicle for many celebrities who have gone on to play much bigger roles in other movies and TV shows. With a 15-year run, it's easy to forget the guest stars on Supernatural, particularly back in those early seasons. 

Here is a list of celebrities on Supernatural that you might've forgotten about or missed on the first watch.


  • Finn Wolfhard, Before 'Stranger Things' And 'It'

    Finn Wolfhard rose in popularity due to Stranger Things, but had his first dark fantasy outing in Supernatural. Here, he played Jordie Pinsky, a boy who's left an orphan after the Darkness spreads her influence around the world.

    312 votes
    Forgot about this?
  • Alden Ehrenreich, Before 'Solo'

    The Solo: A Star Wars Story actor had his first onscreen role ever more than a decade prior on Supernatural as Ben Collins, a teenager who teams up with the Winchesters to locate his elder brother after he's taken captive by a Wendigo.

    266 votes
    Forgot about this?
  • Cory Monteith, Before 'Glee'

    Back when the actor hadn't made it big with Glee, he played the part of Gary on Supernatural, one of the people the Wendigo goes after before Sam and Dean arrive to investigate.

    279 votes
    Forgot about this?
  • The Miz, WWE Superstar

    The WWE Superstar, known for his in-ring career and The Marine film series, appeared as fictional wrestler Shawn Harley on Supernatural, who is targeted by an organization run by a demon and is sacrificed when he refuses to sell his soul.

    216 votes
    Forgot about this?
  • Dylan Minnette, Before '13 Reasons Why' 

    Fans might not recognize him as a little kid, but Dylan Minnette - who plays Clay Jensen on the Netflix series 13 Reasons Why - appeared on Supernatural as one of the children of a family that are victims of a vicious pair of siblings the characters mistake to be ghosts.

    227 votes
    Forgot about this?
  • Ashley Benson, Before 'Pretty Little Liars'

    A few years before her most popular role on Pretty Little Liars, Ashley Benson played another character full of deceit in Tracy on Supernatural, a centuries' old witch who's been posing as a teenager to lure people and bring the demon Samhain from Hell. 

    244 votes
    Forgot about this?